One of the five men committed a murder on March 17 (St. Patrick's Day.) Each made one false statement and three true statements. Who is the murderer?
| Otto | I was in Chicago. | I'm innocent. | The Kid did it . | I know now Mickey. |
| Curly | I'm innocent. | Never owned gun | The Kid knows me. | I was in Detroit. |
| Slim | Curly owns a gun. | The murder was on St. Patrick's day. | Otto was in Chicago. | One of us did it. |
| Mickey | I'm innocent. | The Kid was never in Pontiac. | I don't know Otto. | Curly & me were in Detroit. |
| The Kid | I'm innocent. | I've never been in Pontiac . | I don't know Curly. |
Otto erred when he said I did it. |